I first heard of Nokturnal Mortum several months after Moscow-based Metal
Agen Records released their album 'Lunar Poetry'. Not knowing anything at
all about black metal, I was kind of amused when I saw someone's painted
face in the pages of then very good Russian youth-oriented newspaper 'Ya
Molodoi' (I am young). In those very pages one of the band members (I do
not remember who it was) was courteous enough to provide some insights on
both music and ideology of Nokturnal Mortum. He stated that band promoted
'peaceful paganism' and did not approve of either church burnings nor
killing Christians. According to him, they just wanted to worship their
ancient gods and exist alongside Christian religion without any
Nokturnal Mortum 'Nechrist' |
references and here you have the new NM lyrics. It would be an
understatement to say that I got very upset with such an approach, and
thus I visited The End Records Forum and posted a message where I
presented my feelings and emotions on this disgraceful action of both the
band and the record company (you can view the whole discussion on The End
homepage). I won't comment on each and every reply I got there, but I
would like to take this opportunity to take a look on what Andreas
Katsambas (sorry if I misspelled it), one of the founders of The End had
to say regarding this subject. Point #1: artistic freedom, thus leave
them alone. Well, it really saddens me that people will try to defend
just about anything citing artistic freedom as the key. Should we then
allow anybody to do anything, because she/he is entitled to artistic or
any other kind of freedom? What about the Golden Rule? What about moral
values? Does not matter? And if you say hedonism, then I have to say that
the best thing for me in this case is to trash NM - it is my freedom to
do so. Now, what really sickens me is that people will mention artistic
freedom as long as this freedom does not threaten their own existence and
benefits. That's why I asked Andreas how would he react if NM was singing
about dead Greeks and not dead Jews. Reply? He said he does not even know
if they do. Not knowing is easy, I guess. Well, it was not my point to
ask him if he knows or not, but to find out his reaction if it was the
case... Misunderstanding? You decide. As for the other 'oatmeal people'
(thanx Wendy!) defending pseudo-artistic freedom, they reminded me of
this talentless crappy Nazi band Absurd who got very upset when German
Police pushed them around along with their shitty label No Colors. 'Hey,
it's a democratic country' - they wept, those totalitarian fanatics,
haha. Point #2: extreme Metal is EXTREME. First of all (yes, I have to
say it again!), I do have moral values and I wish more people had some
too, instead of blindly consuming anything that brings them satisfaction
not thinking about consequences or anything at all. Barriers have to be
there (I am talking about internal ones), and you can not hide behind
extremity or anything else in such cases. Andreas tried to compare NM to
Emperor and Dissection - not a very good idea. While I do not really
approve of what either Faust or Jon did, I must remind you that their
actions were directed against single persons and not against particular
group of people, based on these people's national/racial origin. You
could say what about strong anti-Christian position of bands like
Dissection, Marduk, Dark Funeral etc? Firstly, I do not take them as
seriously (it does not mean I ignore their statements) as NM, because I
lived to Russia for 20 years and I know how much Jews are hated by
nationalists of all kinds in Slavonic countries. But more importantly,
you can not say that nazism/racism is equal to anti-Christianity for one
simple reason: you are not born Christian (believe it or not!) and you
can eventually change/abandon your religion if you have guts/brain to do
it, but you can not change you race/nationality even if you live through
the complete blood transfusion - you will live and die the way you were
born. Period. You hear me Mike G? Point #3: NM and Black Metal in general
should not be taken seriously. Does not sit well with point #2, does it?
Again we have a comparison here, this time with Cannibal Corpse and
Deicide. I don't really think Cannibal Corpse would construct a real Tomb
of the Mutilated, but I think that Glen Benton, given a chance, would
love to take away some Christians. As for NM, I am afraid they are quite
serious in their meaningless hatred towards Jews. Anyway, if you, as an
owner of the label, disagree with band's philosophy and do not take them
seriously, why not make it public from day one? OK people, I guess we are
running late here - I could make hundred more points, but it would be too
much for anyone (including myself) to take. I also wanted to note that I
understand that this review does not really look like one, but rather
qualifies for an essay, but my decision is to present it to you as a
review, because I strongly believe that music and ideology go hand in
hand and can not be separated (even if sometimes I wish it could be
possible). I also realize that some of you could be still interested in
actual sounds found on the recording in question. Well, it's good, but I
don't buy rotten product no matter what kind of attractive packaging they
put it in. And the last and very important point: all the arguments
presented here are NORMATIVE rather than POSITIVE statements, which means
that they probably include as much emotion and feeling as they do logic
and common sense. Implications? Well, if you come here with skepticism
and negative attitude, you are most likely to leave this site in the same
state of mind, and there is not much I can do about it. But if you are
like me, if you are more than just a consumer looking for the best deal
possible, if you want and are able to think, then, hopefully, this
writing will make all the difference in this stinky world. And, by the
way, fuck Nokturnal Mortum!
Andy. |